Friday, April 23, 2021

"How About An Oscar For 'Most Prophetic Film?'" (An Updated Reprise First Posted March 3, 2014)

Javert
Tony Perkins

Alan: There "should" be an Oscar for "Most Prophetic Film" in the original sense of "prophetic" which derives from propheteia, Greek for "the gift of interpreting the will of the gods." 

In secular terms, prophecy arises from an individual's  harmonic alignment with The Good.

What criteria would be used for "Most Prophetic Film"?

I suggest The Academy focus those movies that best illustrate the conflict between good and evil, and t
he "winner" will be that film which best harkens "the better angels of our nature." 

Naysayers will argue the thorny difficulties defining "good" and "evil," a conundrum made more dicey by the prevalent sense of moral relativism, and justifiable misgivings that "intended good" often morphs into monstrous evil. 

"The terrible thing about our time is precisely the ease with which theories can be put into practice.  The more perfect, the more idealistic the theories, the more dreadful is their realization.  We are at last beginning to rediscover what perhaps men knew better in very ancient times, in primitive times before utopias were thought of: that liberty is bound up with imperfection, and that limitations, imperfections, errors are not only unavoidable but also salutary. The best is not the ideal.  Where what is theoretically best is imposed on everyone as the norm, then there is no longer any room even to be good.  The best, imposed as a norm, becomes evil.”  
"Conjectures of a Guilty Bystander,” by Trappist monk, Father Thomas Merton

More Merton Quotes


"The road to Hell is paved with good intentions." 

Not always, but often.

The intrinsic muddle-of-morality makes an Oscar for "Most Prophetic Film" fertile ground for the exploration of "virtue," "vice" and the moral hazards accompanying each. 

If the word "vice" conjures the prissiness of "church ladies," recall the other word rooted therein: "vicious." http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=vicious

In the absence of aspiration informed by inspiration, homo sapiens can only "progress" in the aimless sense of "moving forward" without lodestar, direction or goal. 

In large part we find ourselves in continual moral muddle because we presume the impropriety of probing "first principles," preferring instead the indolence of ignore-ance.

In this milieu, Rugged Individualism wins by default, its crazed supporters representing The Common Good and The General Welfare as socialist plots. 

Fear has become America's default "virtue." 

"The Paranoid Style In American Politics," By Richard Hofstadter
paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2012/01/paranoid-style-in-american-politics-by.html

Faulty Risk Assessment: "Self-Terrorization Is The National Pastime"

The United States Of Paranoia

Donald Trump: The Paranoid Style In American Politics And The Ongoing Festival Of Hatred


As the motto of the Republican Party puts it: "We are all in this... alone."

Enter The Academy.  http://oscar.go.com/

Despite its fondness for bloodlust, degradation and edgy antinomianism, Hollywood might wisely conceive the "morality play of cinema" with an eye to "where we are going" and "why."


Remember.

Nothing is certain, not even an end to Holocaust. 


Indeed, it is an inconvenient truth that ethnically "pure" societies run more smoothly than ethnically diverse ones. 


And so we hush the monstrous "reasonability" of Hitler's Final Solution.

We are not noble savages.

Routinely we are savages of the worst sort.

How You And I And Everyone Can Create REAL Damning Evidence To Justify Any Damn Thing - Divorce; One's Religious Faith As "The One, True Religion"; Donald Trump As A Godsend; The Advisability Of Provoking Armageddon, Hitler's Heinous Extermination Of Jews




The above quote fact checks.




Image result for blaise pascal devout christian
Devout Christian, Blaise Pascal

"Aggressive Ignorance And Christianity's Failure To Champion Truth"

To be clear, the nature of The Good is not self-evident. 

Rather, its definition is obscure and uncertain, recalling "angels on pinheads" and contentious debate. 

Lest we forget...

A sizable percentage of American citizens would eliminate Social Security and Medicare. 

An even greater number would repeal Medicaid.


***

Two nights ago, "my" Danny and I saw "Les Miserables" presented by The Gallery Players in Burlington, North Carolina.  http://www.burlingtonnc.gov/index.aspx?NID=219

The abiding appeal of Hugo's epic -- like the attraction of Dickens' Christmas Carol, Tolstoy's Anna Karenina, Cervantes' Quijote, Hamlet, Madame Bovary, Moby Dick, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Grapes of Wrath, The Idiot, The Stranger, Things Fall Apart -- is its unrelenting emphasis on the moral nub of the human condition. 


Where do our hearts lie?


Do we seek vengeance, vindictiveness, retribution and retaliation? http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/581485/talion


Or do we seek, mercy, compassion, love, forgiveness and service?

It is true that these perennial concerns are not the only ones, but they are The Foundation.

"Business!" cried Morley's Ghost, wringing his hands, berating Scrooge. "Mankind was my business. The common welfare was my business: charity, mercy, forbearance, and benevolence were all my business. The dealings of my trade were but a drop in the comprehensive ocean of my business!" http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/A_Christmas_Carol

Unlike the titillating vagaries of Pulp Fiction and Fargo, humankind's moral concerns are indispensable.

The questions themselves are so important that we should, at least, have opportunity to "get them wrong."


Chesterton observed: "If a thing is worth doing, it is worth doing badly."

Whether we laud or lambaste a "Prophetic Film Oscar," such an award would have a huge following and provoke widespread debate. Such an Oscar might even displace "Best Picture" as The Academy's most closely watched and ardently discussed award. 

Even those who hold prophecy in contempt will indulge it as a "guilty" pleasure.

  1. We love our chains!
    1. "A Christmas Carol: Dickens' Inquiry Into The Conservative Psyche"  http://paxonbothhouses.blogspot.com/2015/12/a-christmas-carol-inquiry-into.html
  2. In closing, note that "The Great Novels" -- unlike The Academy's "Best Movies" -- grapple with the conflict between good and evil, and more to the point with the nature of "the good." The Academy is disproportionately dedicated to the prurient "description" of evil, a perverse and ultimately desperate manifestation of American exhibitionism which is - and always has been -- the most seductive form of pornography.

The Age-Old Normalization Of Warfare Through Stupidity, Ego And Religion


  1. The Modern Library's Lists of Top 100 Novels As Chosen By Staff And Readers  


    1. ULYSSESby James Joyce
    2. THE GREAT GATSBYby F. Scott Fitzgerald
    3. A PORTRAIT OF THE ARTIST AS A YOUNG MANby James Joyce
    4. LOLITAby Vladimir Nabokov
    5. BRAVE NEW WORLDby AldousHuxley
    6. THE SOUND AND THE FURYby William Faulkner
    7. CATCH-22by Joseph Heller
    8. DARKNESS AT NOONby Arthur Koestler
    9. SONS AND LOVERSby D.H. Lawrence
    10. THE GRAPES OF WRATHby John Steinbeck
    11. UNDER THE VOLCANOby Malcolm Lowry
    12. THE WAY OF ALL FLESHby Samuel Butler
    13. 1984by George Orwell
    14. I, CLAUDIUSby Robert Graves
    15. TO THE LIGHTHOUSEby Virginia Woolf
    16. AN AMERICAN TRAGEDYby Theodore Dreiser
    17. THE HEART IS A LONELY HUNTERby Carson McCullers
    18. SLAUGHTERHOUSE-FIVEby Kurt Vonnegut
    19. INVISIBLE MANby Ralph Ellison
    20. NATIVE SONby Richard Wright
    21. HENDERSON THE RAIN KINGby Saul Bellow
    22. APPOINTMENT IN SAMARRAby John O’Hara
    23. U.S.A.(trilogy)by John Dos Passos
    24. WINESBURG, OHIOby Sherwood Anderson
    25. A PASSAGE TO INDIAby E.M. Forster
    26. THE WINGS OF THE DOVEby Henry James
    27. THE AMBASSADORSby Henry James
    28. TENDER IS THE NIGHTby F. Scott Fitzgerald
    29. THE STUDS LONIGAN TRILOGYby James T. Farrell
    30. THE GOOD SOLDIERby Ford Madox Ford
    31. ANIMAL FARMby George Orwell
    32. THE GOLDEN BOWLby Henry James
    33. SISTER CARRIEby Theodore Dreiser
    34. A HANDFUL OF DUSTby Evelyn Waugh
    35. AS I LAY DYINGby William Faulkner
    36. ALL THE KING’S MENby Robert Penn Warren
    37. THE BRIDGE OF SAN LUIS REYby Thornton Wilder
    38. HOWARDS ENDby E.M. Forster
    39. GO TELL IT ON THE MOUNTAINby James Baldwin
    40. THE HEART OF THE MATTERby Graham Greene
    41. LORD OF THE FLIESby William Golding
    42. DELIVERANCEby James Dickey
    43. A DANCE TO THE MUSIC OF TIME (series)by Anthony Powell
    44. POINT COUNTER POINTby AldousHuxley
    45. THE SUN ALSO RISESby Ernest Hemingway
    46. THE SECRET AGENTby Joseph Conrad
    47. NOSTROMOby Joseph Conrad
    48. THE RAINBOWby D.H. Lawrence
    49. WOMEN IN LOVEby D.H. Lawrence
    50. TROPIC OF CANCERby Henry Miller
    51. THE NAKED AND THE DEADby Norman Mailer
    52. PORTNOY’S COMPLAINTby Philip Roth
    53. PALE FIREby Vladimir Nabokov
    54. LIGHT IN AUGUSTby William Faulkner
    55. ON THE ROADby Jack Kerouac
    56. THE MALTESE FALCONby Dashiell Hammett
    57. PARADE’S ENDby Ford Madox Ford
    58. THE AGE OF INNOCENCEby Edith Wharton
    59. ZULEIKA DOBSONby Max Beerbohm
    60. THE MOVIEGOERby Walker Percy
    61. DEATH COMES FOR THE ARCHBISHOPby Willa Cather
    62. FROM HERE TO ETERNITYby James Jones
    63. THE WAPSHOT CHRONICLESby John Cheever
    64. THE CATCHER IN THE RYEby J.D. Salinger
    65. A CLOCKWORK ORANGEby Anthony Burgess
    66. OF HUMAN BONDAGEby W. Somerset Maugham
    67. HEART OF DARKNESSby Joseph Conrad
    68. MAIN STREETby Sinclair Lewis
    69. THE HOUSE OF MIRTHby Edith Wharton
    70. THE ALEXANDRIA QUARTETby Lawrence Durell
    71. A HIGH WIND IN JAMAICAby Richard Hughes
    72. A HOUSE FOR MR BISWASby V.S. Naipaul
    73. THE DAY OF THE LOCUSTby Nathanael West
    74. A FAREWELL TO ARMSby Ernest Hemingway
    75. SCOOPby Evelyn Waugh
    76. THE PRIME OF MISS JEAN BRODIEby Muriel Spark
    77. FINNEGANS WAKEby James Joyce
    78. KIMby Rudyard Kipling
    79. A ROOM WITH A VIEWby E.M. Forster
    80. BRIDESHEAD REVISITEDby Evelyn Waugh
    81. THE ADVENTURES OF AUGIE MARCHby Saul Bellow
    82. ANGLE OF REPOSEby Wallace Stegner
    83. A BEND IN THE RIVERby V.S. Naipaul
    84. THE DEATH OF THE HEARTby Elizabeth Bowen
    85. LORD JIMby Joseph Conrad
    86. RAGTIMEby E.L. Doctorow
    87. THE OLD WIVES’ TALEby Arnold Bennett
    88. THE CALL OF THE WILDby Jack London
    89. LOVINGby Henry Green
    90. MIDNIGHT’S CHILDRENby Salman Rushdie
    91. TOBACCO ROADby Erskine Caldwell
    92. IRONWEEDby William Kennedy
    93. THE MAGUSby John Fowles
    94. WIDE SARGASSO SEAby Jean Rhys
    95. UNDER THE NETby Iris Murdoch
    96. SOPHIE’S CHOICEby William Styron
    97. THE SHELTERING SKYby Paul Bowles
    98. THE POSTMAN ALWAYS RINGS TWICEby James M. Cain
    99. THE GINGER MANby J.P. Donleavy
    100. THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONSby Booth Tarkington

    1. ATLAS SHRUGGEDby Ayn Rand
    2. THE FOUNTAINHEADby Ayn Rand
    3. BATTLEFIELD EARTHby L. Ron Hubbard
    4. THE LORD OF THE RINGSby J.R.R. Tolkien
    5. TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRDby Harper Lee
    6. 1984by George Orwell
    7. ANTHEMby Ayn Rand
    8. WE THE LIVINGby Ayn Rand
    9. MISSION EARTHby L. Ron Hubbard
    10. FEARby L. Ron Hubbard
    11. ULYSSESby James Joyce
    12. CATCH-22by Joseph Heller
    13. THE GREAT GATSBYby F. Scott Fitzgerald
    14. DUNEby Frank Herbert
    15. THE MOON IS A HARSH MISTRESSby Robert Heinlein
    16. STRANGER IN A STRANGE LANDby Robert Heinlein
    17. A TOWN LIKE ALICEby Nevil Shute
    18. BRAVE NEW WORLDby Aldous Huxley
    19. THE CATCHER IN THE RYEby J.D. Salinger
    20. ANIMAL FARMby George Orwell
    21. GRAVITY’S RAINBOWby Thomas Pynchon
    22. THE GRAPES OF WRATHby John Steinbeck
    23. SLAUGHTERHOUSE FIVEby Kurt Vonnegut
    24. GONE WITH THE WINDby Margaret Mitchell
    25. LORD OF THE FLIESby William Golding
    26. SHANEby Jack Schaefer
    27. TRUSTEE FROM THE TOOLROOMby Nevil Shute
    28. A PRAYER FOR OWEN MEANYby John Irving
    29. THE STANDby Stephen King
    30. THE FRENCH LIEUTENANT’S WOMANby John Fowles
    31. BELOVEDby Toni Morrison
    32. THE WORM OUROBOROSby E.R. Eddison
    33. THE SOUND AND THE FURYby William Faulkner
    34. LOLITAby Vladimir Nabokov
    35. MOONHEARTby Charles de Lint
    36. ABSALOM, ABSALOM!by William Faulkner
    37. OF HUMAN BONDAGEby W. Somerset Maugham
    38. WISE BLOODby Flannery O’Connor
    39. UNDER THE VOLCANOby Malcolm Lowry
    40. FIFTH BUSINESSby Robertson Davies
    41. SOMEPLACE TO BE FLYINGby Charles de Lint
    42. ON THE ROADby Jack Kerouac
    43. HEART OF DARKNESSby Joseph Conrad
    44. YARROWby Charles de Lint
    45. AT THE MOUNTAINS OF MADNESSby H.P. Lovecraft
    46. ONE LONELY NIGHTby Mickey Spillane
    47. MEMORY AND DREAMby Charles de Lint
    48. TO THE LIGHTHOUSEby Virginia Woolf
    49. THE MOVIEGOERby Walker Percy
    50. TRADERby Charles de Lint
    51. THE HITCHHIKER’S GUIDE TO THE GALAXYby Douglas Adams
    52. THE HEART IS A LONELY HUNTERby Carson McCullers
    53. THE HANDMAID’S TALEby Margaret Atwood
    54. BLOOD MERIDIANby Cormac McCarthy
    55. A CLOCKWORK ORANGEby Anthony Burgess
    56. ON THE BEACHby Nevil Shute
    57. A PORTRAIT OF THE ARTIST AS A YOUNG MANby James Joyce
    58. GREENMANTLEby Charles de Lint
    59. ENDER’S GAMEby Orson Scott Card
    60. THE LITTLE COUNTRYby Charles de Lint
    61. THE RECOGNITIONSby William Gaddis
    62. STARSHIP TROOPERSby Robert Heinlein
    63. THE SUN ALSO RISESby Ernest Hemingway
    64. THE WORLD ACCORDING TO GARPby John Irving
    65. SOMETHING WICKED THIS WAY COMESby Ray Bradbury
    66. THE HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSEby Shirley Jackson
    67. AS I LAY DYINGby William Faulkner
    68. TROPIC OF CANCERby Henry Miller
    69. INVISIBLE MANby Ralph Ellison
    70. THE WOOD WIFEby Terri Windling
    71. THE MAGUSby John Fowles
    72. THE DOOR INTO SUMMERby Robert Heinlein
    73. ZEN AND THE ART OF MOTORCYCLE MAINTENANCEby Robert Pirsig
    74. I, CLAUDIUSby Robert Graves
    75. THE CALL OF THE WILDby Jack London
    76. AT SWIM-TWO-BIRDSby Flann O’Brien
    77. FARENHEIT 451by Ray Bradbury
    78. ARROWSMITHby Sinclair Lewis
    79. WATERSHIP DOWNby Richard Adams
    80. NAKED LUNCHby William S. Burroughs
    81. THE HUNT FOR RED OCTOBERby Tom Clancy
    82. GUILTY PLEASURESby Laurell K. Hamilton
    83. THE PUPPET MASTERSby Robert Heinlein
    84. ITby Stephen King
    85. V.by Thomas Pynchon
    86. DOUBLE STARby Robert Heinlein
    87. CITIZEN OF THE GALAXYby Robert Heinlein
    88. BRIDESHEAD REVISITEDby Evelyn Waugh
    89. LIGHT IN AUGUSTby William Faulkner
    90. ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO’S NESTby Ken Kesey
    91. A FAREWELL TO ARMSby Ernest Hemingway
    92. THE SHELTERING SKYby Paul Bowles
    93. SOMETIMES A GREAT NOTIONby Ken Kesey
    94. MY ANTONIAby Willa Cather
    95. MULENGROby Charles de Lint
    96. SUTTREEby Cormac McCarthy
    97. MYTHAGO WOODby Robert Holdstock
    98. ILLUSIONSby Richard Bach
    99. THE CUNNING MANby Robertson Davies
    100. THE SATANIC VERSESby Salman Rushdie


No comments:

Post a Comment